Aries and Pisces in depth
Aries and Pisces at a glance
Aries is the first sign of the zodiac and Pisces the last, so the two are neighbours: Pisces comes immediately before Aries, thirty degrees away around the circle. Aries is a fire sign, cardinal in quality, ruled by Mars. Pisces is a water sign, mutable in quality, ruled by Jupiter. One sign ends the year and the next begins it, and in the old scheme two signs side by side make no aspect at all.
This site's sun-sign method scores the pair at 46 out of 100 on the KundliToday Compatibility Index, "a challenging match that rewards patience". The arithmetic: fire and water are one of the element pairings the method rates lowest, which gives a base of 52; signs one apart, the neighbours with no aspect, take away 6; and neither sign is on a list of especially good or especially hard partners for the other, so the list adjustment is 0. 52 - 6 = 46. It is a traditional rule-based editorial score, not a measured probability, and it says nothing about how two real people will get on.
What makes the pair interesting is the nature of the gap. Aries and Pisces are not opposed, as Aries and Libra are, and they are not at a right angle, as Aries and Cancer are. They are adjacent, and Ptolemy's word for signs in that position is "inconjunct", which he explains as "averted, as it were, from each other". It is a neutral word, not a hostile one. The pair simply do not look at each other directly. One is brisk, outward and certain; the other is receptive, inward and doubtful. Each sees in the other something it lacks and sometimes something it fears.
The two signs
Aries: the starter
Alan Leo's Key to Your Own Nativity describes Aries rising as "a cardinal, movable, and fiery sign", giving "much energy and activity both of body and mind, much impulse and enthusiasm, with many changes in the course of life". The person is "courageous, enterprising, frank and outspoken", can "face difficulties promptly and bravely", and is "ambitious, self reliant, and adventurous". The Sun in Aries "increases the energetic, active, and impulsive side of your nature" and brings "independence and self confidence"; yet "when you meet with opposition you are inclined to be rather wilful, rash, and pugnacious".
In Astrology for All the Sun in Aries is "force and energy" and "an ambitious, aspiring, and enthusiastic nature", fitted "for positions of authority and responsibility". He does not leave out the hard side: the person may be "militant in disposition and manner, domineering, irritable, intolerant of opposition or contradiction, hard and unyielding". With "the softening influence of Venus or Jupiter" the harsher phases may be removed, "otherwise he will be a tyrant or a rebel". And elsewhere: "This person needs the steadying influence of Saturn, otherwise he may be a slave to impulse." How to Judge a Nativity gives the sign's natives as "enthusiastic, pioneering, ambitious, militant, enterprising, independent, assertive, and self-willed".
In a relationship Aries moves first, speaks plainly, forgets a quarrel quickly and dislikes being managed.
Pisces: the last sign
Alan Leo opens his chapter by calling Pisces "the last sign of the zodiac, the sign of the fishes", the last of the watery and mutable signs. The symbol is "two fishes tied together, one swimming in one direction and the other in the opposite". He admits that it is "somewhat difficult to express all that is conveyed in the symbol of this sign", and that the sign is called "the sign of self-undoing". Its people are "emotional and secretive, patient and meditative, kind and generous, imitative, receptive and peaceful when living up to the best of their nature". They are "very receptive to all the conditions that are around them", and find it "very difficult to become fully individualised". The chapter's last sentence gives the inner nature of the sign as "Spirituality".
In the same book the Sun in Pisces makes the individual nature "emotional and receptive, meditative and imitative", "not the strongest of the twelve signs" but giving "a very deep internal nature". There are "two types of individuals under the sign Pisces, the undeveloped and the developed", of whom "the latter are extremely altruistic characters, filled with an inexhaustible love for all created beings". The hard side is stated as plainly: when undeveloped the people are "over-restless and over-anxious", "undecided how to act, and always waiting for an opportunity".
In a relationship Pisces is tender, imaginative and absorbing of the other person's moods, and is slow to say what it wants.
What they share and where they differ
Fire and water
Sepharial matches each element to a temperament: "the inspirational and ardent temperament is indicated by the majority of planets being in Fiery signs", "the psychic or emotional temperament by the majority in Watery signs". Alan Leo's Art of Synthesis is blunt about the two together: the four triplicities "are always harmonious in themselves, but are not harmonious when opposed to triplicities of a diverse character such as the fiery and watery, or the fiery and earthy triplicities; water quenching fire, and earth smothering it". That is the oldest and plainest objection to this pair, and it is why the method rates the element combination low.
The same book, though, puts something on the other side of the ledger. Of the fiery triplicity it says that it "is the torch or flame from which the other triplicities are lighted", and of Pisces, in the watery triplicity, that "the emotions are active in deep sympathy" and that the highest aspect of the sign is "the sign of compassion and true hospitality". Our own reading is that the image of fire quenched by water is only half of what water does to fire: it also gives fire something to warm. Aries may be steadied by Pisces's softness, and Pisces may be given courage by Aries.
The Key has a passage on a horoscope with "the Sun in a Fiery and the Moon in a Watery sign", which says the person "will be very receptive to your surroundings, and will often take on the conditions of other persons and think that their conditions are your own". That is about one chart, but it describes the feel of this pair well: a fire sign's drive working through a water sign's sensitivity.
Cardinal and mutable
Sepharial's list is "Movable, Aries, Cancer, Libra, Capricornus" and "Flexed, Gemini, Virgo, Sagittarius, Pisces". Alan Leo's description of the difference is the one to hold on to. Cardinal is "the prompt, rapid and decisive change of the movable quality", and the mutable signs resemble the cardinal in being "often productive of change, but this is generally due to their adaptability and duality of nature". Aries changes things on purpose. Pisces changes because it drifts, adapts and follows. Sepharial's picture is the wheel: "the cardinal signs denote the rim or tyre which is ever on the move", while the common signs are "the spokes of the wheel, uniting the tyre to the nave, and in that sense representing the power of adaptability".
The Art of Synthesis goes on to say the mutable signs "make better and more fortunate servants than masters", and that they "require a great deal of support from other influences to bring out the best that is in them". It gives them "too much duality, a proneness to vacillation, irresolution, to 'sit on the fence' and to shirk responsibility". And it says Aries wants "to be at the head of things". This is the structural fit and mismatch of the pair in one line. Aries wants a follower or a partner who will go with the lead, and Pisces is the sign best at going with. But Pisces is not a servant in any lesser sense; the book calls the mutable signs "good agents, intermediaries, interpreters, commentators, counsellors, advisers". A good Pisces advises Aries and sees what Aries misses.
How to Judge a Nativity adds a note on Aries with the mutable signs: "when combined with the common signs it is less practical and methodical than with the fixed but is very rapid, comprehensive, and subtle". That is a generous reading of the combination, and it is a statement about one nature and not about two.
Neighbouring signs: no aspect
Ptolemy gives four aspects, at 60, 90, 120 and 180 degrees. Signs one apart are none of them. In Ashmand's translation of the Tetrabiblos, "all signs, between which there does not exist any familiarity in any of the modes above specified, are inconjunct and separated", and signs "distant from each other in the space of one sign only are considered inconjunct, because they are averted, as it were, from each other". The word is neutral. It says the two signs have no relation, not that they are enemies.
Manilius, in Creech's 1697 verse paraphrase, is more pointed: "In Concord no Contiguous Signs agree, / For what can love when 'tis deny'd to see?" That is a seventeenth-century verse rendering, not a literal text, and it speaks of signs, not people. Lilly's aspects chapter does not cover neighbours at all. All three authors are concerned with planets and positions in a chart.
Ptolemy's gender rule points the same way. Aries, the first sign, is masculine, and the signs "are arranged in alternate order", so Pisces, the twelfth, is feminine. In his geometry, signs of different gender are the ones that make the "discordant" aspects. Aries and Pisces differ in gender but make no aspect, which in his language leaves them unrelated and not at odds. Our own reading is that this fits the experience: the pair seldom clash head on, because they seldom meet head on. They drift past each other, or one gets absorbed in the other.
There is also a point about order that the books do not make but that is worth noticing. Ptolemy says that the beginning of the whole zodiacal circle is "assumed to be the sign of Aries", and Leo calls Pisces the last sign. The pair are therefore the end of one round and the start of the next. That is our own observation, not a doctrine.
Mars and Jupiter: the two rulers
Sepharial's list gives "Mars governs Aries and Scorpio" and "Jupiter governs Pisces and Sagittarius". Ptolemy's reasons for the assignments are in his chapter on the houses of the planets. Jupiter's signs stand at "trinal distance from the houses of the luminaries, which distance harmonises with the operation of good". Mars's signs are at distances that are "injurious and discordant". That is Ptolemy's account of why one planet is called benefic and the other malefic.
In The Art of Synthesis, Mars is energy that needs a channel: "Force must have some outlet either in well-guided energy or else in mere impulse and passions, but just as crude pig iron may be changed into fine steel, so may all destructiveness or passion be changed into fortitude or courage." Jupiter is "a representative of the 'higher mind' in man, not as pure reason but as innate wisdom, expansive, unifying, and harmonising".
Put the two together, in our own words: a pair where one partner supplies the drive and the other the breadth. Mars asks, "what shall we do?" and Jupiter asks, "what is it for?" At their best that is a very good conversation. At their worst Mars takes Jupiter's generosity for slackness and Jupiter takes Mars's directness for narrowness. Leo's Key also has a revealing note on Mars in Pisces: "Mars shows less of its fire and impulsiveness than it does in most of the signs, and it is accompanied by a good deal of reserve". This is about Mars as a planet in a Pisces chart, but it shows how the books expect water to cool fire.
Falling in love: attraction, feeling and affection
Attraction and the beginning
The beginning is often a mix of fascination and incomprehension. Aries is "frank and outspoken", and what Aries notices in Pisces is the receptive manner, the sympathy, the interest that does not push. What Pisces notices in Aries is the courage and the clarity: here is someone who knows what they want. Alan Leo says the Pisces type is "very receptive to all the conditions that are around them", and Aries, who is sure of itself, can feel in the company of a Pisces unusually understood.
Our own reading is that Aries pursues and Pisces responds, and that this works well for a while. The risk at the start is projection. Aries may see in Pisces the gentle audience it wanted, and Pisces may see in Aries the protector it hoped for. Neither is quite the person the other imagines.
Feeling and the heart
The books are clear that Pisces feels deeply. How to Judge a Nativity says that in Pisces "all is turned into emotion, which like the ocean is deep, silent, and inexpressible". Venus is exalted in Pisces, and the Key says Venus in Pisces, "the exaltation of this planet", "should bring you success in love affairs". Aries feels quickly and plainly, then moves on. The books give it "devotion to persons or causes", along with "some liability to arouse enmity through disputatiousness".
So the two have different clocks. Aries's anger flares and is gone by evening. Pisces's hurt is quiet and may last for days without a word. The risk is that Aries thinks all is well, because Aries has forgotten, while Pisces is still carrying the matter. Alan Leo says that nearly all Pisces people "pretend to be something different from what they really are", and we read that as meaning that a Pisces partner may say "I'm fine" when they are not.
Affection and intimacy
On intimacy the books are restrained and so is this section. The tenderness of the pair is likely to be unequal in style: Aries warm, direct and generous, Pisces gentle, imaginative and absorbed in the moment. The practical need is for each to learn the other's signals. Aries may need to slow down and attend to a quiet partner's cues. Pisces may need to say aloud what is wanted, because Aries will not guess.
Talking to each other
Talk between the two is the pair's first test. Aries speaks briefly and plainly; the Pisces way is to circle, to hint, to wait for the other to notice. Leo describes the type as "undecided how to act", "emotional and secretive". An Aries partner who asks a direct question and gets a vague answer will press harder, and a Pisces partner who is pressed may say what the other wants to hear or say nothing.
The two Sun-and-Moon passages give a picture of the same difficulty inside single charts. For the Sun in Aries with the Moon in Pisces, Leo says the combination "is not altogether a harmonious one, the action of the Sun being too strong for the lunar position, producing a discontented, restless, and often worrying nature". For the Sun in Pisces with the Moon in Aries, "there is positiveness, force, energy and activity, though of a rather restless and unsettled kind", and the person is "easily led if not easily driven". Those are portraits of the two signs meeting within one person, and they point to the same two themes, restlessness and unease.
The practical rule, our own, is that Aries should ask open questions and wait for the answer, and Pisces should answer the question that was asked, before the question behind it. A regular time for each to say what is on their mind, without a decision attached, would help both.
Trust and loyalty
The books give each sign its own kind of loyalty. Aries has "devotion to persons or causes" and a frankness that makes it easy to trust: what it thinks, it says. Pisces is "kind and generous", "patient and meditative", with "an inexhaustible love for all created beings" when developed. Both qualities are real, and they appeal to trust of different kinds. Aries is trustworthy in the open; Pisces is trustworthy in the dark, when someone needs to be heard.
There are warnings on both sides. Aries, unsoftened, may be "a tyrant or a rebel", which is a risk to a quieter partner. Leo says that when Pisces is undeveloped it is "a bundle of inconsistencies tied with the cord of discontent", and that a good deal of its character comes from "a lack of decision". In practice, trust is strained when Aries feels that Pisces is vague and Pisces feels that Aries is forceful. Each needs evidence that the other means well. An Aries partner shows it by patience; a Pisces partner by plain speech.
Leo's Sun-and-Moon passage for the Sun in Aries with the Moon in Pisces adds a warning that could be read as a hint for the pair: those born under it "may suffer from scandal or slander and from secret enmity; but they must guard themselves against behaving in the same way to other people". The sentence is about one person, and we take no rule from it beyond the plain one: a hurt that is not spoken tends to come out sideways.
Marriage and commitment
What the books say
The books give no marriage rule for Aries and Pisces. Alan Leo's one passage in Astrology for All on whom the Aries type would marry well names other signs and does not mention Pisces. What the books give is the general doctrine above, and the two one-person passages. The first, for the Sun in Aries with the Moon in Pisces, says the combination "tones down considerably the impulsiveness of Aries", and that "when the two are working harmoniously, it increases the kindliness of the nature". It adds that "usually, however, much sorrow comes into the life, which causes those born under it to think more deeply than those under most of the Aries combinations". The second, for the Sun in Pisces with the Moon in Aries, says it "considerably strengthens the individual character, adds more force and energy to the Pisces sign, and gives more self-reliance", but that new causes "are taken up eagerly, though sometimes with too much haste". Leo also judges another combination "not quite so unfortunate as the combination of Sun in Aries and Moon in Pisces". That is his verdict on a single chart.
None of this is a rule for two people. It shows that Leo expected the blend of fire and water inside one person to be difficult and, if worked through, deepening.
A practical reading
This section is our own synthesis. A marriage of an Aries and a Pisces is a partnership of a doer and a feeler. Each supplies what the other lacks: Aries gives direction and protection, and Pisces gives sympathy, imagination and a sense of what matters. The couples who do well agree an explicit division. Aries leads on decisions that need speed and courage, Pisces leads on matters of feeling, care and the household's mood, and each defers in the other's area.
The usual difficulties are predictable. Aries may become impatient with a slow decision, and Pisces may feel overruled. A Pisces partner may avoid saying "no" and then resent the result. Because Pisces absorbs the mood of the house, an Aries partner's temper can weigh on it more than Aries realises. Regular, unhurried talk, and a rule that no major decision is made in anger, protect the marriage better than any compatibility score.
For the Indian reading of marriage compatibility, which is worked out from the Moon's birth star and not from the Sun sign, see Kundli Milan, and note that the Vedic and Western zodiacs differ by about 24 degrees (see Vedic and Western astrology compared).
Money, home and family
Money
Aries earns boldly and spends freely. The Pisces side, in the books, is more mixed. Leo's Sun in Pisces has "a tendency to economy and carefulness, in small matters especially", but it is also "decidedly more scattering than acquisitive if taken alone" in one polarity, and Pisces people do best in "any employment that brings some kind of change". Sepharial gives Aries "soldiers and pioneers of movements" and Pisces "dealers in fish and sea produce, warders, and those connected with places of confinement, such as prisons and hospitals".
For a couple, the likelihood is an unpredictable income and a need for a plan. Our own suggestion is a joint account for fixed costs, a savings habit set up in advance, and a personal allowance for each, so that Aries's impulse purchases and Pisces's generosity do not meet in the same account.
Friendship and work
As colleagues
At work the pair can be good complements. Aries starts and decides, Pisces completes and advises. Leo says Pisces people do well in pursuits "where they may complete the work of others", and the mutable signs "make good agents, intermediaries, interpreters". The friction comes when authority is unclear. Pisces may feel overridden, and Aries may feel that Pisces is slow to commit. A clear owner for each task settles most of this.
Where they clash
Directness
Aries says it straight; Pisces hears it as a blow. Leo's description of Aries as "frank and outspoken" and "intolerant of opposition" is the key to the pair's commonest hurt. Aries has said something blunt and moved on, and Pisces is still carrying it. Aries can learn to soften a message and Pisces can learn to answer it at once.
The undeclared grievance
The Pisces habit, as Leo describes it, is to be "secretive" and to "pretend" to be what it is not. A grievance that is not stated hardens. Aries then meets a wall without having seen a quarrel. The remedy is a standing question, asked by Aries and meant: "Is there anything I have said or done that you are carrying?"
Strengths and challenges
Strengths of the pair
The pair's strengths are the ones the signs lack in each other. Aries brings courage, initiative, honesty and the will to protect. Pisces brings sympathy, imagination, patience and the ability to listen. Both are generous. In the books' language, fire is "the torch" from which the other triplicities are lit, and the watery sign Pisces is "the sign of compassion and true hospitality". A couple who use the gifts well make a household that is both brave and kind.
Challenges of the pair
The challenges are the same pairs reversed. Aries's directness can wound; Pisces's silence can frustrate. Aries moves on and Pisces stays. Aries needs decisions; Pisces needs time. Pisces's habit of absorbing the other's mood can drain it, and Aries's habit of ignoring such moods can leave Pisces unsupported. The pair also differ in how they handle stress: Aries acts and Pisces withdraws, so a crisis can pull them in opposite directions.
Long-term prospects
Over a long relationship the pair's differences can either wear into resentment or soften into respect. Leo's remark about Pisces, that the "inner nature and final destiny of this sign is Spirituality", and his note that the Aries combination with Pisces yields people who "think more deeply", suggest that the later years may favour the deeper side. In our reading a pair who have learned to say what they feel, to decide at a pace both can bear and to value each other's gifts may be more settled in age than they were at the start. The worst version is the pair who stop talking, Aries busy elsewhere and Pisces withdrawn. The best is the pair who have become each other's complement, with Aries's courage tempered and Pisces's gentleness given a spine. The books describe two signs and leave the rest to the two people.
How the Compatibility Index is worked out, and what it is not
The KundliToday Compatibility Index on this page, 46 out of 100, is a traditional, rule-based editorial score. It starts from a base set by the elements (82 for the same element, 76 for fire with air or earth with water, 52 otherwise), adds or subtracts points for the angle between the signs (+2 same sign, −6 neighbours, +4 sextile, −8 square, +8 trine, −10 quincunx, +6 opposition), and adds 4 for each sign that lists the other among its best partners or subtracts 4 for its trickiest partners. The two list adjustments are averaged, so the index is the same whichever sign is named first, and the total is kept between 35 and 97. For Aries and Pisces the sum is 52 − 6 = 46.
The weights are an editorial convention. The old authors did not assign points, and the weights have not been fitted to data, so the index is not a scientifically validated probability that a relationship will work, and a gap of a few points between two pairs means nothing.
The closest empirical test we have read in full is Helgertz and Scott (2020, Genus 76:34). It did not test this index. It took the sun-sign compatibility tables of six free astrology websites and compared them with 66,063 marriages, and for divorce 46,326 marriages (14,920 of them ended in divorce), of Nordic-born couples in Swedish registers from 1968 to 2001. It found no consistent support: marriages were not more common among "compatible" sign pairs than chance predicts, and the divorce hazard ratios stayed between about 0.94 and 1.04, with the few nominally significant ones small and not following the sites' rankings. The study concerns Western sun-sign tables, legal marriage and legal divorce, in one country and period. It did not test Vedic matching such as Kundli Milan, moon or rising signs, or full chart comparison, and it says nothing about happiness inside a marriage. Read the index as a summary of how a set of traditional rules classifies two signs, and as nothing more.
Realistic illustrations
These are illustrations, not real couples, and they are drawn only from the sign characters above.
The unanswered question
An Aries partner asks whether the family should move for a new job. The Pisces partner says "maybe" and changes the subject. Aries hears yes and starts to plan. Two days later Pisces is distressed and unable to say why. They agree to a rule: Aries asks the big question a day early, and Pisces gives an answer, even if it is "I am not sure yet, ask me on Friday".
Beyond sun signs
A sun-sign reading is the beginning of an analysis, not the end. Two people with the Sun in Aries and in Pisces may have a Moon, a Venus or a rising sign that changes the picture, and Alan Leo's two passages above are about exactly such combinations inside one chart. For more, look at the Moon sign, which describes emotional needs, with the moon sign calculator, the rising sign, which describes the manner each presents, with the rising sign calculator, and all three at once with the big three calculator. The synastry calculator compares the two full charts planet by planet, and the aspects page explains how each aspect is worked out.
In the Vedic tradition the Western Aries corresponds roughly to the rashi Mesha, whose stars include Ashwini, and Pisces to Meena, whose stars include Revati. See the individual signs, Aries and Pisces, their daily forecasts (Aries, Pisces), related pairings such as Aries and Cancer and Aries and Gemini, and the full list in sign compatibility.
Frequently asked questions
Are Aries and Pisces compatible? On this site's sun-sign method the pair scores 46 out of 100, a challenging match that rewards patience. They are fire and water, cardinal and mutable, and neighbours with no aspect. The books give no rule for two people, and their two passages concern single charts. The score is a convention, not a measured probability.
Is Aries and Pisces a good match for marriage? It can be, with work. The usual difficulties are speed, directness and unspoken grievances, and each can be handled by agreement in advance. Alan Leo's passages on the Sun in one sign with the Moon in the other describe one person's chart and give no marriage rule.
Who leads in an Aries and Pisces relationship? Aries will take the lead on decisions and action, and Pisces is the sign of the books' good adviser. The pair do best when Aries asks and listens, and Pisces speaks up.
Does a sun-sign match decide a relationship? No. The large Swedish register study by Helgertz and Scott found no consistent evidence that astrologically more compatible couples were overrepresented among marriages or had a lower risk of divorce. A Sun sign describes a type; the Moon, the rising sign and the two people decide the rest.
References
- Alan Leo, Astrology for All (1910), the chapter on the sign Pisces, the passages on the Sun in Aries and on the Sun in Pisces, and the polarities of the Sun in Aries with the Moon in Pisces and the Sun in Pisces with the Moon in Aries. About the author ↗
- Alan Leo, The Key to Your Own Nativity (1910), the passages on Aries rising, the Sun in Aries, Mars in Pisces, Venus in Pisces and the Sun in a fiery sign with the Moon in a watery one. About the author ↗
- Alan Leo, How to Judge a Nativity (1903), the chapter on the twelve signs, the passages on Aries and on Pisces as the last of the watery signs. About the author ↗
- Alan Leo, The Art of Synthesis (1912), the chapters on the mutable and cardinal qualities, on the triplicities and on Mars and Jupiter. About the author ↗
- Sepharial, Astrology: How to Make and Read Your Own Horoscope (1904), the chapters on the elements, the constitutions, the rulers of the signs and the choice of occupation. About the author ↗
- Claudius Ptolemy, Tetrabiblos (translated by J. M. Ashmand, 1822 (Foulsham reprint, 1900; Project Gutenberg no. 70850)), Book I, the chapters on the annual seasons, the masculine and feminine signs, the houses of the planets and the signs 'inconjunct', in Ashmand's translation. About the author ↗
- Marcus Manilius, translated by Thomas Creech, The Five Books of M. Manilius (London, 1697 (verse translation)), Book II, the passage on contiguous signs, in Creech's 1697 verse translation. About the author ↗
- Joakim Helgertz and Kirk Scott, The validity of astrological predictions on marriage and divorce: a longitudinal analysis of Swedish register data (Genus 76:34, 2020, open access (CC BY 4.0)), the full text: data and methods, Tables 3 and 4, and the discussion of limitations. About the author ↗
Quotations are from the public-domain English books named above. Astrology is a traditional system of interpretation, not a scientifically established way to predict a relationship. All our sources →